It's formal night and of course nothing goes as planned. Cause as everyone knows, it's not a prom if no one winds up crying in the bathroom.

Nathan's mood isn't the best ever: he's been waiting for Haley, while she was having a secret rehearsal with Chris. And when Nathan learns that his wife has been secretly singing with Chris since his trip to Charlotte, he isn't exactly thrilled. Haley points out that this is not about Chris. Besides, even though she is sorry Nathan didn't get into High Flyers, it's not fair for him to take it out on her. Nathan suggests that she go home and look in his top drawer. "You'll see a letter from High Flyers. Read that. Then talk to me about fair."

Meanwhile, Brooke finds out that it wasn't Felix who took care of her the night she was drunk. And it turns out Brooke has to tell Felix something. "I am not gonna let you in! You don't get to have me; not my body and sure as hell not my heart! We're done".

Peyton is wearing her mother's dress but she feels miserable and lonely. Even Felix treats her badly and hints, - totally out of the blue - that she is a lesbian. Anna agrees with her brother, saying: "Yeah. Don't be so gay, Peyton." Our beloved Goldilocks is really hurt, since Anna was supposed to be her friend.

Dan tells Lucas he knows he backed out of the HCM test. Lucas replies that, at least, he is not lying about the results, as Dan has. "Your doc told me you aced the test. Guess you were planning on keeping that to yourself." Dan assures he is only trying to get his family back.

After getting drunk, Anna wants to have sex with Lucas, but he stops her saying they should slow down. So, she backs off, wondering why she is having such a contradictory behavior. Then she points out she needs to be alone.

It turns out Peyton is tempted to do cocaine again, but, luckily, she ends up trowing the drug away.

Dan tells Deb the truth about his health condition. As soon as he claims he is ready to move out of their home, Deb stops him: she wants to give him another opportunity, but Mr. Scott had better not mess things up again, because this is his very last chance.

Later, Lucas catches up with Brooke, who can't stop wondering why everyone seems to enjoy lying to her. "You know, the bad guys lie to get in your bed... and the good guys... lie to get in your heart. And I'm the idiot that falls for it every time." After throwing out wise gems, Lucas gets Brooke home.